The men felt the need to attend as a sign of respect to a fallen monument. Discuss the endings for both stories. Her actions are contradictory: This approach is the refusal to acknowledge the existence of the problem. Different people handle problems in different ways. Homer Barron her supposed lover died in her upstairs bedroom and she never moved him, but bought him toiletries, and a suit.
While some solve the problem immediately, some try to run away from them, while others choose an approach that is more extreme. She believes that she herself also plays a role in this play, an important role that Miss brill and miss emily be missed were she not there to play it. Teaching a few children how to paint China, which was perceived as outdates and useless craft that no longer interested people is the only thing that Emily did with people.
Miss Brill leaves soon after, not buying her usual slice of honey-cake on the way. This shows the extremes that Emily could go in an effort to suppress her grief and sorrow.
What do the ironies reveal? We learn in the end that Emily poisons Homer during that last visit when he is seen entering her house, and then she keeps his dead body for decades. Although she tried to escape reality, it was made obvious that she could not.
However, the couple does not satisfy her, because they part ways before anything meaningfully interesting can be said. Once again, she tried to avoid the reality of the present. The ending to the story was an indeterminate ending where there was not clear and concise conclusion but rather left the reader to draw conclusions.
She was raised thinking she was above everyone else. In her mind, as she watches people, she creates incredible scenarios in which she imagines that the park is a massive theater and that everyone at the park is taking part in a big play.
Another would be the idea that Miss Brill was in a performance rather than reality. What do the ironies reveal? The fact that Miss Bill took community interest to a totally different level is what differentiates her from Emily Grierson.
Ossa Certified Educator The similarities between Miss Brill and Miss Emily Grierson stem from the fact that the two women are examples of extreme isolation and its effects on the psyche, and the spirit, of those who experience it. Miss Brill had the same weekly, or maybe even daily, routine.
A major similarity between Emily and Brill is that they both lacked romantic and prosaic relationships in their lives. She also hears them making fun of her fur. When her father died she was faced with reality, which was something that she did not seem prepared for.
What type of ending is it? Miss Brill for instance goes to the garden every Sunday to observe everyone, but she imagines it as if it were a play she were in and that the garden is her stage.
Miss Emily avoided reality by strictly living insider her house and refusing to pay taxes because she claimed she did not have taxes in Jefferson. Also it is an example of dramatic irony because the reader knows that the event that takes place every Sunday is not really a play like Miss Brill imagines it to be.
Their key difference is how each woman tries to regain control of her situation. She decides to kill Homer because of the inner knowledge that he could be gay.
Neither woman ever ended up with a genuine social life, even though their public lives varied significantly. A good example is the manner in which Miss Brill is in denial regarding her aging. Emily preferred to be left alone. She wanted to feel included in society and hoped people would converse with her while sitting on the bench in the park.
Miss Brill displays dramatic and situational irony. She imagines the world as being a stage and she is just an actress in it.Get an answer for 'Compare and contrast the character of Miss Brill in "Miss Brill" with the character of Emily Grierson in “A Rose for Emily."' and find homework help for other Miss Brill.
Miss Brill in Katherine Mansfield’ short story “Miss Brill” and Emily in “A Rose for Emily” by William Faulkner exhibits interesting similarities and differences. Mar 27, · Miss Brill and Miss Emily are two single older ladies that live in their own world.
Miss Brill was thrilled to put on her fur and the fact she could have placed it in her lap and pet it. Mar 28, · In “Miss Brill,” Miss Brill also tries to avoid reality, but in a different manner than Emily.
Miss Brill tried to escape reality by dressing up in her “fur” and going to the park every Sunday because she felt as if she was an important part of the events that took place.
Miss Brill is a middle-aged woman who spends her days as a teacher for children and as a reader for an old man who hardly recognizes her existence. Every Sunday she wears her shabby fur coa t to the French public park called Jardins Publiques.
She speaks to the coat as if speaking to another person. Apr 30, · The tragedy of Miss Emily’s life is a common reality that was repeated in the lives of many belles in post civil war United States. in works like William Faulkner's “A Rose for Emily,” Katherine Mansfield's “Miss Brill,” and Kate Chopin's “The Storm,” the female protagonists are examples of how society has oppressive.Download